Tax Hotline

Taxation of outsourcing activity - Morgan Stanley ruling analyzed

Further to our hotline “Supreme Court rules on permanent establishment in the outsourcing industry” dated July 9, 2007, please click here to read our analysis (published in the Worldwide Tax Daily: 2007 WTD 142-5) of the judgment in the case of DIT (International Taxation), Mumbai v. Morgan Stanley and Co. Inc. In its ruling the Supreme Court held that that the outsourcing of services such as back-office operations to a captive service provider will not per se create a permanent establishment ("PE") of the parent in India. This was a key consideration, as in case outsourcing were to cause a PE  of the non-resident company in India, the global profits of the non-resident company attributable to the PE may have been taxable in India at the rate of approximately 42.23%(approximately). Further, the availability of tax credit for such tax paid in the home jurisdiction may be uncertain, thus potentially leading to double taxation and wiping out the economic advantage of outsourcing to India. The Supreme Court has held that the presence of employees for stewardship functions will not constitute a service PE, whereas deputation of employees may create a service PE. Therefore foreign companies need to be careful in structuring inter-country assignments henceforth. It has also accepted the single-entity approach for the attribution of profits to a PE by ruling that the payment of an arm’s-length price by the nonresident to the PE extinguishes any further attribution of profits to tax.

Hope you find the analysis informative.

Best regards,

Taxteam

Disclaimer

The contents of this hotline should not be construed as legal opinion. View detailed disclaimer.

This hotline does not constitute a legal opinion and may contain information generated using various artificial intelligence (AI) tools or assistants, including but not limited to our in-house tool, NaiDA. We strive to ensure the highest quality and accuracy of our content and services. Nishith Desai Associates is committed to the responsible use of AI tools, maintaining client confidentiality, and adhering to strict data protection policies to safeguard your information.

This hotline provides general information existing at the time of preparation. The Hotline is intended as a news update and Nishith Desai Associates neither assumes nor accepts any responsibility for any loss arising to any person acting or refraining from acting as a result of any material contained in this Hotline. It is recommended that professional advice be taken based on the specific facts and circumstances. This hotline does not substitute the need to refer to the original pronouncements.

This is not a spam email. You have received this email because you have either requested for it or someone must have suggested your name. Since India has no anti-spamming law, we refer to the US directive, which states that a email cannot be considered spam if it contains the sender's contact information, which this email does. In case this email doesn't concern you, please unsubscribe from mailing list.